• Home
  • Parashah Insights
  • Ask the Rabbi
  • Festivals & Fasts
  • Articles
  • Books
  • About

    Who is the Shema talking to? – Ask the Rabbi

    Q. Who is the Shema talking to?

    A. It is not a prayer so it is not addressing God. It is a proclamation calling upon the people of Israel to hear two announcements – “HaShem is our God”, “HaShem is One”.

    Possibly there is a dialogue here, a responsive proclamation. The speaker, Moses, says, “HaShem is our God!” and the people respond, “HaShem is One!” (or, “HaShem the One”).

    “One” can be taken in a mathematical sense, 1 as against 2 (making it an anti-dualistic polemic), 1 as against 3 (i.e. anti-trinitarian), 1 as against many (i.e. anti-polythistic), 1 as against none (i.e. anti-atheistic).

    Alternatively it means “unique and incomparable”.

    Rashi sees a messianic implication in the word “our”: the God who now is “ours” will eventually be accepted by the whole world as the one God of all humanity.

    Comments are closed.