• Home
  • Parashah Insights
  • Ask the Rabbi
  • Festivals & Fasts
  • Articles
  • Books
  • About

    By-passing the establishment – Re’eh

    Uncle-SamThe Torah does not at all approve of people choosing to do that which is right in their own eyes (Deut. 12:8).

    Being a law unto yourself may be an expression of your individualism, but it can gravely endanger society. If you detach yourself from accepted norms and standards and do only what you yourself fancy, you risk causing chaos for civilisation.

    This is so axiomatic in Jewish thinking that for all our obvious dedication to the dignity of the individual we cannot possibly approve of people doing their own thing regardless.

    In a metaphorical sense there is also a danger in people who have no problem with codes of ethics still wanting to do their own thing by excluding themselves from the established community.

    Judaism emphasises the importance of both the individual and of the community. But when the community needs the individual, they must be there to be counted and counted on.

    If the minyan needs you and you decline to be the tenth man, the rabbis say you are a bad neighbour. If you have a talent which you refuse to make available to society, you are like the bottle of scent to which the Midrash refers when it says that one should be Abraham, who shared his insights with the world, and not like the person who says, “I am keeping my bottle of scent to myself”.

    A practical illustration of the problem is those in a community who do not affiliate to a congregation, pay nothing either in money or involvement towards the maintenance of community services, and then fully expect that the rabbis and facilities of the congregation will automatically be made available to them when needed.

    Example: “I came to the synagogue on Kol Nidrei night and they would not let me in because I wasn’t a member”… If everyone decided not to be a member there would be no synagogue or service.

    Example: “My family do not belong to a shule, but why was it so hard to find a minister to conduct my relative’s funeral?”… Ministers do their best if they have time, but their first priority is their own congregants.

    Certainly, if there are financial problems and someone simply cannot afford membership fees every assistance is given without question – but what about those who can afford to belong and do not bother, relying on the kindly nature of the rabbi/minister/congregation when needed? Fair is fair!

    Comments are closed.